Friday 20 November 2026

Editorial

Organ trafficking, state silence and selective response: Haiti faces a crisis of public legality

By Emmanuel Taulème BRINA

· 2 min read

Share

This article is also available in Français, Español and Kreyòl ayisyen

Homme en costume bleu souriant tenant des documents devant un tableau blanc

LEGAL EDITORIAL — Emmanuel Tauleme BRINA

The public statements by gang leader “Lanmò San Jou” targeting Andy Apaid, particularly the accusations involving human remains and allegations of organ trafficking, require an immediate institutional response under public law.

In any state governed by the rule of law, allegations this serious require the opening of an independent judicial investigation.

That is not what happened.

The PNH, long inactive in the face of abuses committed in Croix-des-Bouquets, suddenly carried out massive operations only after the revelations were made public. This timing raises legitimate questions about:

  • the neutrality of police action,
  • the possible protection of private interests,
  • and the violation of the principle of equality before the law.

As a legal expert, I recall that:

  • The Haitian Constitution requires that the impartiality of public authority be guaranteed.
  • The state has an obligation to investigate any potential attack on human life and dignity, regardless of the social status of those involved.
  • Failure to act can constitute gross negligence by the administration, engaging its liability.

The necessary call: truth, transparency, justice

This is not about giving credence to the words of a criminal.
It is about recognizing that the facts raised are too serious to be covered up and too weighty to be ignored.

Haiti cannot keep covering up scandals when they involve the powerful while brutally crushing those who have only their words and their weapons to exist in a country in ruins.

For this reason, I publicly call for:

  1. The immediate opening of an independent judicial investigation into the allegations of organ trafficking, the land concerned and the bones found.
  2. An official statement from the PNH explaining the timing of and reasons for its lightning operation.
  3. A guarantee that the investigation will not be manipulated or silenced by networks of economic and political influence.

Haiti can no longer be governed by shadows, unspoken alliances and opportunistic police operations.

Conclusion: Truth has no allies … but it has witnesses

Faced with the most serious accusations, with a silence that smacks of collusion and with a police force that acts too late and too fast, I choose the side of truth, even when it is uncomfortable.

History will remember that some chose their comfort.
As a journalist and legal expert, I choose my duty.

The country is entitled to impartial justice, not selective justice.

Emmanuel Tauleme BRINA
Journalist – Public Law Specialist

Share