Monday 16 November 2026

Justice

ONA: The Emmanuel Ménard Case as a Symptom of State Impunity

By Jenny Toussaint

· 1 min read

Share

This article is also available in Français and Kreyòl ayisyen

Yon gason nan biwo li ak kostim ak kravat chita devan yon biwo ak papye

The abuse-of-office case against Emmanuel Ménard at the National Old-Age Insurance Office (ONA) cannot be reduced to a mere administrative matter. It is a real institutional test for the Haitian state.

When reports from the Anti-Corruption Unit (ULCC) and the Central Financial Intelligence Unit (UCREF) get lost in judicial limbo, it is the rule of law itself that falters.

According to an investigation by the organization Ensemble contre la corruption (ECC), reports sent by the ULCC and UCREF languish in a disorganized judicial system, where more than 42% of case files are said to be missing. That figure alone shows the scale of the dysfunction.

Procedural inaction, the lack of a reliable archiving system and poor case tracking feed a culture of systemic impunity that undermines the credibility of institutions.

Yet the ONA manages workers’ social savings. Any suspicion of wrongdoing in such an institution carries a particularly sensitive ethical, social and political dimension.

Without structural reform of the justice system, full digitization of procedures and the creation of a specialized financial crimes unit able to handle economic and financial cases effectively, the fight against corruption will remain an empty slogan, unable to restore public trust.

Share

Jenny Toussaint

Journaliste-Rédactrice à Hebdo24 | Politicienne | Experte en Relations Internationales 📩 : jenny@hebdo24.com Suivez-moi sur X : @jennyhebdo24

All articles